From Italy With Integrity
Our olive oils from Italy are olives from Puglia, Tuscany or Sicily or a mix. The quality is all the same but varies in nuances.
Perfect for gifting
How to use it:
The Everyday Italian Pear-ing
$47.00
Sale
Everything starts with two. Our peppery, first-pressed Italian Olive Oil meets our glossy, aged Traditional Balsamic Vinegar—the exact pair a busy kitchen runs out of first. No flavors to overthink, no special occasion required. Just honest, delicious ingredients to build every weekday dinner and weekend gathering on. If you own nothing else, own these two.
Includes:
-
TDPCO Italian Olive Oil
-
TDPCO Balsamic Vinegar
Taste notes
Buttery
Peppery
Rich
Slightly Sweet
What's inside
-
TDPCO Italian Olive Oil
The workhorse. Peppery, unfussy, and good on nearly anything — the bottle a kitchen runs out of first.
-
TDPCO Balsamic Vinegar
Aged and glossy — the half of every great dressing that most pantries are missing.
Secure Checkout
30-Day Returns
Live Support
Everything starts with two. Our peppery, first-pressed Italian Olive Oil meets our glossy, aged Traditional Balsamic Vinegar—the exact pair a busy kitchen runs out of first. No flavors to overthink, no special occasion required. Just honest, delicious ingredients to build every weekday dinner and weekend gathering on. If you own nothing else, own these two.
Includes:
-
TDPCO Italian Olive Oil
-
TDPCO Balsamic Vinegar
Shipping
- Ships from Midway, Utah
- Standard shipping: 3-5 business days
- Free shipping on orders over $100
Returns
- In-Store Purchases: Eligible items can be returned within 7 days of purchase to your original form of payment or for store credit.
- Online Orders: Eligible items can be returned within 14 days of the original purchase date to your original form of payment or for store credit.
- Item Condition: Items must be unused, unwashed, and in their original condition. A valid sales receipt or proof of purchase is required for all returns.
- To ensure the safety, freshness, and quality of our products, all food items and clothing purchases are final sale and cannot be returned or exchanged. All antique and vintage art is one of a kind and is also final sale.
The Everyday Italian Pear-ing
$47.00
How to use it:
The Everyday Italian Pear-ing
$47.00
A Measure of Excellence
EVOO must have acidity up to 0.8%
Our oils average 0.2% and range from 0.1% - 0.3%.
Brighter Flavor
Greater Freshness
Longer Lasting Quality
18 months
Our olive oils maintain their peak quality for up to 18 months from the date of bottling.
Best by: 18 months
Young Olives Premium Oil
The greener the olive, the higher the antioxidants and polyphenols-and the more vibrant the flavor. Early harvest means less yield, but exceptional quality.
What Makes Us Different
Grocery Store
OIL & VINEGAR
- Generic blends
- Mass produced
- One-dimensional flavor
- Limited guidance
- Unkown origin
Dainty PEAR-ING
- Produced and harvested
- Small batch
- Curated pairings
- Recipes & pairing ideas
- Verified Italian origin
Our Promise
The Dainty Pear Co. Difference
We started The Dainty Pear Co. because we believe great cooking begins with great ingredients — not complicated recipes. Every product we curate is chosen with the same care we bring to our own kitchen. We source from trusted small producers, taste everything ourselves, and only share what we'd proudly serve to our own guests.
312+
5-Star Reviews
4.8/5
Average Rating
12K+
Happy Customers
100%
Natural Sourcing
312+
5-Star Reviews
4.8/5
Average Rating
12K+
Happy Customers
100%
Natural Sourcing
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this suitable as a gift?
Yes. The pairing arrives in gift-ready packaging loved by both new cooks and seasoned hosts.
How long do the bottles last once opened?
For best flavor, enjoy within a few months of opening. Store in a cool, dark place with the cap sealed.
Is the olive oil certified organic?
We source from trusted small Italian producers. Certification details are listed on each bottle label.
What is your shipping and return policy?
Orders ship from our warehouse. If something arrives damaged, contact us and we will make it right.
Can I order in bulk for corporate gifting?
Yes. Reach out for bulk and corporate gifting options, including custom quantities and timing.